Hi All,

My preference is Scenario 3, followed by 1 and lastly 2.

I think scenario 3 is the most challenging as well as the most rewarding one to work on, for 2 main reasons. John, the key character, is presented in the context of a relatively more complex web of human relationships than the other 2 scenarios. In addition, the problems here cover most of the issues presented in scenario 1, other than those related to the application of pedagogy. So, overall it offers a greater scope for exploration. Secondly, the root of the problem appears to be a family break-up, a situation not covered in the other 2 scenarios. Based on our course outline, this apparently isn't a topic that going to be covered in great depth. Yet, it is a very real and important issue which we will all face in the profession, and hence included as a choice in this assignment. So, whatever we learn from this project will be beneficial for us. Perhaps also, what we finally present will more likely be original and a direct reflection of our group's unique perspective and creativity.

Scenario 2 was rather limited to issues of pedagogy. So not much prospects there.

Based on all our votes, it looks like scenario 3 is it. Ade, are you OK with this?

Suggestion:
Before our next meeting this Wed:
(1) Let's discuss the problems we have each identified in the scenes for 3. I think we need to consider how we will present it. For example, I started by profiling John based on his cognitive, social, moral and emotional state of development.

(2) As we do (1), let's relate the problems identified to theories. We haven't come across many of them yet but can certainly ask questions that will direct us towards them during our research i.e. identify the "gaps" in our curent knowledge and understanding.

(3) Come up with a problem statement.

I agree with Aloy that Blogger may not be the best form of communication. Thanks for suggesting an alternative, Aloy. Shall check out wordpress shortly.